Best Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Brookline, MA

Looking for a bagel breakfast that actually delivers on taste and quality in Brookline, Massachusetts? Just 15 minutes away in Cambridge, Brooklyn Bagel Factory serves up authentic, water-boiled, NY-style bagel sandwiches stacked with premium meats, cheeses, spreads, and veggies.

Whether you’re commuting from Coolidge Corner, working from Washington Square, or heading to school near Longwood, our bagel sandwiches are the flavorful fuel your mornings need.

🔥 Why Brookline, MA Locals Crave Brooklyn Bagel Factory’s Fresh Bagels

✅ Authentic NY-Style Bagels – Hand-rolled, water-boiled, and baked fresh daily for that perfect golden crust and soft chew inside

✅ Just 15 Minutes from Brookline, MA – Fast delivery and easy access from Brookline neighborhoods like Coolidge Corner, Washington Square & Brookline Hills

✅ Coffee + Sandwich Combo – Pair your favorite sandwich with our smooth cold brew, rich drip coffee, or energizing espresso drinks for the ultimate Brookline breakfast combo.

✅ Signature Bagel Sandwiches That Hit the Spot
From classic combos like Egg & Cheese on an Everything Bagel to modern creations like our Smoked Turkey & Avocado with Spicy Aioli, our bagel sandwiches are packed with flavor and made to order.

✅ Fully Customizable Sandwich Experience
Pick your base (Plain, Sesame, Everything, or Gluten-Free), then choose your eggs, cheese, meats (turkey, bacon, sausage), vegan spreads, fresh veggies, and signature sauces. Whether you like it classic or creative, we build your perfect bite.

✅ Hearty & Filling – Any Time of Day
Great for a hearty breakfast, a midday brunch, or a quick grab-and-go lunch near Brookline. Our bagel sandwiches are protein-packed, satisfying, and always freshly made.

✅ Vegan & Vegetarian Options Available
Try our Avocado Tomato Smash on Multigrain or the Veggie Supreme with herbed cream cheese — no meat, no problem.

🧇 Signature Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches Loved by Brookline Locals

🧇 1. Smeargle Square Bagel Sandwich – $4.45
Cream cheese smear of your choice (like Jalapeño, Chives, or Nutella) served between two warm Bagels. Add Smoked Salmon or Vegan spread for an extra kick.

🧇 2. Inman Square Bagel Sandwich – $8.25
Two cage-free eggs and your choice of Boar’s Head protein (Bacon, Sausage, Ham, or Turkey Breast) between golden Bagels. A perfect breakfast classic.

🧇 3. Agassiz Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Light smear, egg whites, avocado, tomato, fresh cucumber, alfalfa sprouts, and Parmesan Peppercorn dressing. A refreshing, clean option wrapped in crispy Bagels.

🧇 4. Winthrop Square Bagel Sandwich – $9.45
Eggs, baby ham & turkey breast, cucumbers, tomato, alfalfa sprouts, feta cheese, and cracked black pepper—balanced and bold on toasted Bagels.

🧇 5. Alewife Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Oven gold turkey breast, smoked bacon, cheddar, Swiss cheese, chives cream cheese, and honey Dijon—all melted into soft-yet-crispy Bagel goodness.

🧇 6. Wellington Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Roast beef, smoked bacon, eggs, mixed veggie smear, Wisconsin American cheese, and tangy Texas BBQ sauce. A true carnivore’s dream.

🧇 7. Harrington Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Smoked sausage patty, baby ham, eggs, chives smear, provolone cheese, and chipotle mayo—all grilled into a spicy and savory crunch.

🧇 8. Avon Hill Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Spicy sausage and smoked bacon with jalapeño smear, cheddar cheese, tomato, jalapeños, and sweet & spicy sauce for a fiery breakfast twist.

🧇 9. Brattle Square Smoked Salmon Bagel – $11.99
Smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, cucumber, red onion, alfalfa sprouts, and capers—all held together by warm, lightly sweetened Bagels.

🧇 10. Harvard Square Smoked Salmon Bagel – $12.99
Double smoked salmon with salmon spread, arugula, cucumbers, onions, sprouts, and peppercorn dressing—a brunch-worthy indulgence.

💬 What Brookline Customers Are Saying About Brooklyn Bagel Factory

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Maya R. – Coolidge Corner
“I order the Agassiz almost every week. It’s light but super satisfying. The veggies are always crisp, the dressing is flavorful, and the multigrain bagel gives it that wholesome bite. It’s my go-to after morning yoga!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Jonah K. – Washington Square
“The Alewife is absolutely incredible. The combination of oven-roasted turkey, smoky bacon, and honey Dijon never misses. Plus, delivery to Washington Square is quick and consistent—perfect for my work-from-home days.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Anya S. – Brookline Village
“The Inman Square with sausage is my favorite pre-class breakfast. It’s hot, hearty, and keeps me full till lunch. I always pair it with a cold brew—it’s the morning boost I rely on.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Leo G. – Longwood Medical Area
“I’ve tried bagels all over Boston and Brookline, but the Brattle Square smoked salmon bagel stands out. The salmon is fresh, the veggies are crisp, and the bagel? Absolute perfection.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rebecca T. – Chestnut Hill
“The Avon Hill has that perfect spicy kick. Jalapeños, sausage, and cheddar on a bagel—it wakes me right up! I always add an iced latte for a complete morning pick-me-up.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Miles L. – St. Mary’s Street
“I actually go out of my way to pick up the Wellington sandwich. Roast beef, eggs, BBQ sauce—it’s hearty, bold, and so worth the trip. It’s the kind of breakfast that powers your whole day.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Riya D. – Corey Hill
“When I want something sweet and comforting, I get the Smeargle Square with Nutella. It’s my ‘treat-yourself’ snack after a long week—simple, warm, and just right.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Chris F. – Brookline Hills
“Love that I can customize everything here. My favorite is the Harrington with extra chipotle mayo—spicy, savory, and super satisfying. And ordering online is a breeze.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Samantha J. – Griggs Park
“Easy online ordering, quick pickup, and the staff is always friendly. Bonus: the coffee is surprisingly great—not just an afterthought like at other bagel spots.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Drew P. – Harvard Street
“Brooklyn Bagel Factory has become my weekend ritual. I treat myself to the Harvard Square double-smoked salmon sandwich, and it’s worth every penny. Fresh, indulgent, and beautifully balanced.”

❓Brookline, MA Bagel FAQs – Everything You Need to Know

1. Do you deliver to Brookline, MA?
   ✅ Yes! We offer fast delivery to Coolidge Corner, Brookline Village, Washington Square, and all surrounding Brookline neighborhoods through UberEats, DoorDash, and Grubhub. Your perfect bagel breakfast is just a few clicks away.
2. Are the bagels really handmade?
   ✅ 100%! Each bagel is hand-rolled, water-boiled, and baked fresh every morning in true NY-style tradition. No shortcuts, no frozen dough—just authentic, chewy, golden-brown bagels.
3. What’s the most popular sandwich in Brookline?
   🥯 Brookline locals love the:

• Alewife – a savory powerhouse with turkey, bacon, chive smear, and honey Dijon.
• Agassiz – a lighter, veggie-loaded option with egg whites, avocado, and fresh greens.
  Both are top picks for breakfast, brunch, or midday cravings.

4. Any vegetarian options?
   🌱 Definitely!

• The Smeargle Square is simple, satisfying, and can be customized with spreads like Nutella or jalapeño cream cheese.
• The Agassiz is packed with wholesome veggies and flavor.
  Perfect for meat-free mornings or a clean post-yoga bite.

5. What time do you open?
   ⏰ We open bright and early at 6:00 AM every day, making us a reliable stop for early risers, morning commuters, and anyone who needs a warm bagel and coffee to start the day.
6. Can I build my own sandwich?
   👨‍🍳 Absolutely! Customize your perfect bagel sandwich from start to finish—choose your bagel, egg style, proteins, cheeses, spreads, veggies, and sauces. We love seeing what combos our Brookline regulars come up with!
7. Do you have gluten-free bagels?
   🚫 Not at the moment, but we’re actively testing gluten-free options in our kitchen. Stay tuned to our Instagram or website for updates—we can’t wait to share them with you soon.
8. How far is Brookline from Brooklyn Bagel Factory?
   📍 Just a quick 15-minute ride to Cambridge. Whether you’re biking in from Coolidge Corner or ordering delivery to Brookline Hills, we’re closer than you think—and worth every minute.
9. Do you serve coffee too?
   ☕ Of course! Enjoy your bagel with a cold brew, fresh drip coffee, or bold espresso-based drinks. Our baristas are here early to keep you fueled and caffeinated.
10. Can I dine in?
    🪑 Yes! We have indoor seating available, so you can sit down with your bagel and coffee, catch up with friends, or even get some work done. Prefer to grab and go? We also offer takeout and online ordering for convenience.

📍 Visit or Order from Brooklyn Bagel Factory – A Top-Rated Brookline, MA Breakfast Spot

Craving the best breakfast bagel sandwiches near Brookline, MA? Whether you’re commuting, relaxing, or working from home, Brooklyn Bagel Factory is just a short drive—or delivery—away.

📍 Address:
Brooklyn Bagel Factory
168 Hampshire St, Cambridge, MA 02139
(~15 minutes from Brookline)

📞 Phone:
+1 (617) 945-7286

🌐 Website:
brooklynbagelfactory.com

📦 Order Online: UberEats | DoorDash | Grubhub

Looking For Best Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Massachusetts 

Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Belmont |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Boston |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Arlington |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Cambridge |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Chelsea |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Everett |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Malden |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Medford |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Quincy |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Revere |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Somerville |  Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Watertown