🥯 Best Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Arlington, MA

If you’re in Arlington, Massachusetts, and searching for the perfect breakfast to jumpstart your day, look no further than Brooklyn Bagel Factory in nearby Cambridge. We’re just 15 minutes away and offer the freshest, hand-rolled, water-boiled bagels packed with premium ingredients.

Whether you’re heading to work, walking through Arlington Center, or relaxing on a Sunday morning, our bagel sandwiches deliver the flavor, warmth, and satisfaction you need.

🔥 Why Visit Brooklyn Bagel Factory?

If you’re serious about bagels, this is where you go. Here’s why:

✅ Authentic NY-Style Bagels – Hand-rolled, water-boiled, and baked fresh daily
✅ Massive Local Following – Over 700 glowing reviews from loyal customers across Cambridge and Greater Boston
✅ Creative, Customizable Menu – From spicy jalapeño cheddar to classic lox, there’s a bagel for every craving
✅ Quick Service & Online Ordering – Perfect for busy mornings, remote workers, or weekend brunch lovers
✅ Community Favorite – A go-to breakfast and lunch spot for Harvard students, tech professionals, and local families alike
✅ Top-Rated Coffee Pairings – Enjoy cold brew, espresso, or a classic drip alongside your bagel

🧇 Signature Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches

🧇 1. Smeargle Square Bagel Sandwich – $4.45
Cream cheese smear of your choice (like Jalapeño, Chives, or Nutella) served between two warm Bagels. Add Smoked Salmon or Vegan spread for an extra kick.

🧇 2. Inman Square Bagel Sandwich – $8.25
Two cage-free eggs and your choice of Boar’s Head protein (Bacon, Sausage, Ham, or Turkey Breast) between golden Bagels. A perfect breakfast classic.

🧇 3. Agassiz Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Light smear, egg whites, avocado, tomato, fresh cucumber, alfalfa sprouts, and Parmesan Peppercorn dressing. A refreshing, clean option wrapped in crispy Bagels.

🧇 4. Winthrop Square Bagel Sandwich – $9.45
Eggs, baby ham & turkey breast, cucumbers, tomato, alfalfa sprouts, feta cheese, and cracked black pepper—balanced and bold on toasted Bagels.

🧇 5. Alewife Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Oven gold turkey breast, smoked bacon, cheddar, Swiss cheese, chives cream cheese, and honey Dijon—all melted into soft-yet-crispy Bagel goodness.

🧇 6. Wellington Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Roast beef, smoked bacon, eggs, mixed veggie smear, Wisconsin American cheese, and tangy Texas BBQ sauce. A true carnivore’s dream.

🧇 7. Harrington Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Smoked sausage patty, baby ham, eggs, chives smear, provolone cheese, and chipotle mayo—all grilled into a spicy and savory crunch.

🧇 8. Avon Hill Bagel Sandwich – $8.99
Spicy sausage and smoked bacon with jalapeño smear, cheddar cheese, tomato, jalapeños, and sweet & spicy sauce for a fiery breakfast twist.

🧇 9. Brattle Square Smoked Salmon Bagel – $11.99
Smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, cucumber, red onion, alfalfa sprouts, and capers—all held together by warm, lightly sweetened Bagels.

🧇 10. Harvard Square Smoked Salmon Bagel – $12.99
Double smoked salmon with salmon spread, arugula, cucumbers, onions, sprouts, and peppercorn dressing—a brunch-worthy indulgence.

💬 What Arlington Locals Are Saying

Real Reviews from Your Neighbors Who Can’t Get Enough of Brooklyn Bagel Factory

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Maggie S. – East Arlington
“I drive to Cambridge every Saturday just for the Agassiz on multigrain. It’s light, fresh, and totally addicting! The veggies are always crisp, and the combo hits every time.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tom R. – Arlington Heights
“The Wellington sandwich is my go-to for mornings after long shifts. Roast beef and BBQ on a bagel? Genius. It’s hearty, flavorful, and keeps me going for hours.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sophie W. – Arlington Center
“Smeargle Square with jalapeño cream cheese is simple but perfect. I add lox when I’m feeling fancy—it’s the best of both worlds: spicy and savory.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
David M. – Arlington Reservoir
“I’ve had bagels in NYC, but the Alewife sandwich here is next-level. The turkey and cheese blend is so good—melty, sharp, and served on a warm sesame bagel.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Leah T. – Jason Heights
“The Harrington sandwich was spicy, cheesy, and satisfying. Totally worth the trip to Cambridge—and when I’m lazy, delivery is super fast too!”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Carlos V. – Arlington Heights
“I order the Winthrop Square weekly. The turkey and feta combo is just unmatched. It’s become part of my lunch ritual—always fresh, always flavorful.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Isabella L. – Mystic Lake Area
“I can’t stop ordering the Brattle Square salmon sandwich. It’s the perfect balance of salty and fresh. The red onions and capers seal the deal.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Jared K. – Arlington Center
“Love their online ordering! I get the Inman Square with bacon—it’s ready fast and always hot. Ideal for grab-and-go mornings before work.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Emily B. – Alewife Brook Parkway
“The Avon Hill is my spicy guilty pleasure. Jalapeño smear, sausage, and cheddar on an everything bagel? Elite combo that always hits the spot.”

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Noah F. – Park Ave Area
“Friendly service, killer coffee, and those bagels? Cambridge might be a drive, but Brooklyn Bagel Factory is worth it every single time.”

❓ Frequently Asked Questions – Arlington, MA Bagel Lovers Edition

Everything You Need to Know About Ordering from Brooklyn Bagel Factory

Do you deliver to Arlington, MA?
✅ Yes! We offer fast, reliable delivery to all parts of Arlington—including East Arlington, Arlington Heights, and Arlington Center—via UberEats, DoorDash, and Grubhub. Hot, fresh bagels delivered right to your door.
Are the bagels handmade?
✅ Absolutely. Every bagel is hand-rolled, water-boiled, and baked fresh each morning using traditional New York methods. No shortcuts—just chewy, golden perfection in every bite.
What’s the most popular bagel sandwich in Arlington?
🥯 Our Arlington customers rave about the Alewife (turkey, cheddar, spicy mayo) and the Agassiz (veggie-packed goodness on a multigrain bagel). Both are loaded, flavorful, and made to satisfy.
Do you have vegetarian options?
🌱 Yes! We have several vegetarian-friendly choices. Try the Smeargle Square with veggie or Nutella smear, or go green with the Agassiz, stacked with fresh cucumbers, sprouts, and tomato.
What time do you open?
⏰ We open bright and early at 6:00 AM daily, making us the perfect breakfast stop before your commute, school drop-off, or morning walk around Arlington Reservoir.
Can I customize my sandwich?
👨‍🍳 Definitely! Mix and match your favorite ingredients—choose your bagel base, swap in your preferred protein or cheese, and select from a variety of savory and sweet smears.
Do you offer gluten-free bagels?
🚫 Not yet. We’re currently working on gluten-free options but do not offer them at this time. Follow us on social media or check our website for updates as we expand our menu.
How far is Brooklyn Bagel Factory from Arlington?
📍 We’re located just 15 minutes away in Cambridge, at 168 Hampshire St—an easy drive, bike ride, or quick delivery route. Perfect for weekend brunch or a midday bagel run.
Do you serve coffee with the bagels?
☕ Yes! We serve hot drip coffee, espresso drinks, and cold brew—perfect pairings for any of our signature sandwiches or fresh-baked bagels.
Is there seating available?
🪑 Yes, we offer dine-in seating, as well as takeout and online ordering for pickup or delivery. Whether you want to hang out or grab and go, we’ve got you covered.

📍 Visit or Order from Brooklyn Bagel Factory – Just Minutes from Arlington, MA

Looking for the ultimate bagel experience near Arlington? Whether you’re craving a classic everything bagel or a stacked sandwich like the Alewife or Agassiz, Brooklyn Bagel Factory is just a short drive—or quick delivery—away. Here’s everything you need to know to plan your visit or place an order:

📍 Address:
Brooklyn Bagel Factory
168 Hampshire St, Cambridge, MA 02139
(Conveniently located just 15 minutes from Arlington)

📞 Phone:
+1 (617) 945-7286
Have questions or a custom order? Call us anytime during business hours!

🌐 Website:
brooklynbagelfactory.com
View the full menu, explore bagel sandwich options, or check business hours online.

Online Ordering Available On: UberEats ,DoorDash ,Grubhub

Looking For Best Breakfast Bagel Sandwiches in Massachusetts